So, I just wanted to spitball a bunch of theories for why the democrats are failing in recent years. I mean, as I said, the democrats look like they're getting destroyed right now. And while they aren't quite getting the apocalyptic red wave I would have expected last year, they do seem to be going underwater. For reference, not a ton has changed since my last election forecast for races I was looking at, but polls do show that support for democrats seems to be slipping nationwide. That said, I'm going to discuss various interpretations of this.
1) Governing at the worst possible time
I am a firm believer, after studying a lot of political trends, that certain election cycles, it's better NOT to win. This is one of the reasons I've been so reluctant to support democrats in recent years. Unless we get the right candidate with the right messaging and the right time, it can actually be disastrous to lead. This is because some presidents and the like are remembered poorly just for being in office at the wrong time. Some presidents, like say, James Monroe or Bill Clinton, did do much with their presidencies, but because the economy was strong and there were relatively good conditions during their presidency, they're remembered fondly. But when things go wrong on your watch, it doesn't matter what the cause was, you're gonna be blamed. Take, say, Martin Van Buren, who had the economy crash after Jackson's policies inevitably damaged the economy. Jackson was never really blamed. He was remembered well, because he governed under good times. But Van Buren was, even though he just happened to deal with the fallout and given how...libertarian right the 1800s were economically, the government wasn't really set up to provide relief for people. Also consider presidents like Jimmy Carter who happened to be in charge when everything in the entire world was going wrong at once, or Obama who inherited the 2008 recession fallout from Bush. To be fair, inheriting problems isn't always a bad thing. The "best" presidents are the ones who basically inherited everyone else's crap and came along and fixed the problem. FDR inherited the great depression which happened under hoover, but due to his politicking regarding it, he was able to turn the situation for the better where the people LOVED him. Same with Reagan. He inherited Carter's problems but because they went away on his watch, in part due to policies implemented and in part due to screwery or even dumb luck, things fell into place where Reagan is remembered fondly.
Biden basically inherited Trump's mess. 2020 was bad. 2017-2019 weren't bad comparatively speaking. The economy was suddenly "strong" after it was "weak" under Obama (never mind Trump just inherited the Obama recovery), but then COVID hit and Trump mismanaged it so bad that he actually lost to the democrats, despite the democrats themselves running on weak messaging. I'll get back to weak messaging later on, but first I want to focus on the times. Biden started out strong. He got in, passed some relief, and got some money in peoples' hands, and then the republicans attacked them for it. And the economy reopened, and inflation started roaring, and there was a jobs surplus (yeah, im not calling it a "worker shortage" but a "jobs surplus"), and suddenly all that aid Biden did was being demonized and blamed for everything going wrong, and people believed it. Then Ukraine happened, making gas shoot through the roof as global demand shifted away from Russia. And now we're dealing with OPEC being greedy in a similar way we did in the 1970s. And now the fed is trying to rein in job creation by hiking interest rates, which is now going to cause a recession. And while this happened under Reagan, the democrats are being blamed for it. And they can't really pass anything. Because despite controlling the house and the senate Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema are basically just stalling everything the democrats do, not even allowing them to break out of the filabuster. So the dems are stonewalled. And then when Biden tries to act via executive action, he's being blamed for that because "ThAtS CoNgReSs' JoB!11!!" (note: while congress does control power of the purse, the presidency is in charge of executing the budget, and the Department of Education and the federal student loan program falls under his authority, meaning Biden's actions are legitimate, but to be fair, most people don't know this because our country is ignorant as fudge, but I'll get to that later). And it just seems like nothing Biden or other entities do, it's never going to be good enough.
I'll be discussing the actual faults with the democrats either. I'm not absolving them from responsibility here, but I am just going to say that unless the democrats can govern effectively and solve the problems, they're gonna be blamed, regardless of their fault. And in the case of inflation at least, I honestly think the factors are out of their control and there is no easy fix. The textbook solution to inflation is what the fed is doing in sparking a recession, and right now that's just freaking everyone out. And honestly, given the core sources of inflation aren't so much labor power but corporate greed and supply chain issues (as well as an extremely tight housing market that's being exploited to the greatest extent possible), there aren't good solutions here. This is something that's worldwide, not just affecting us, and there is no easy solution than to just ride it out. But, people have unreasonable and insane expectations, and aren't educated, so they're just going to be like OMFG DO SOMETHING (and despite criticizing the populace here, let me just say I understand the pain that people are under, this is a crap sandwich, but there isn't really an easy or good solution to this, the global economy is complex and the stuff Biden WANTED to do largely stalled in congress because of Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema). Carter had the same issue by the way, although that WAS solved by...the fed crashing the economy in 1982 under Reagan. After which the expansion was considered the the longest in history up to that point, not crashing until the 90s. Given I'm not sure that the core causes of the current problem are the same, I'm not sure crashing the economy would help, but likely plunge people further in pain...
Anyway, Biden is just screwed. As you can tell, he's darned if he does, and darned if he doesn't. it doesnt matter what he does, he can't fix the problem. And while I do blame congress and the democrats somewhat, again, no easy solutions either.
2) The centrist fixation...
Yeah, I'm going to say it, the centrist fixation is directly responsible for a lot of the failures of Biden's presidency. Biden wasn't someone who campaigned on much of an agenda. Bernie did, but he was soundly defeated due to the party organizing to remove other competition from the primary to ensure a 1 v 1 between Biden and Bernie would go about as well as it did vs Hillary in 2016. The result was the centrist faction won, and then ended up going into office with a milquetoast agenda. Still, what scraps Biden delivered were generally popular...when delivered. As Kyle Kulinski of secular talk always says, Biden's approval was at its highest when he was cutting $1400 checks. And it went down when he started hitting roadblocks.
Which, let me talk about that. Biden, despite running on the "electable" guy and "the guy who can get things done", while mocking "pie and the sky" ideas from his competition much in the same way Hillary did, when push came to shove to do anything, he couldn't. Because his own congress gutted his proposals and decided to be a pain in the neck. He couldn't pass build back better, which, by the way, did intend to alleviate the "worker shortage" (or jobs surplus) by giving people free daycare and getting schools back up and running, but, he couldn't pass it. Because Manchin and Sinema...obstructed him. And I just watched Pelosi talk about how we can't get 60 votes in the senate...the only reason we can't is because, once again, the democrats won't remove the filibuster. So...they're dead in the water. They pass very little, what they do pass is very watered down, and they're hampered from taking direct action. And then when Biden DOES act via executive order, you get all the crocodile tears from executive overreach like with student loans. Student loan reduction was popular for the most part, but it isn't helping because OMFG HE DID IT VIA EXECUTIVE ORDER! Uh...again, you realize he's responsible for executing student loan policy right? He can just choose not to enforce the law, change the rules for how student loans are collected, and even just forgive amounts. Of course I dont expect people to know this. But still.
The point is, if you look at what is motivating voters this election, democratic enthusiasm is very low right now, and republican enthusiasm is very high. The democrats haven't whipped up their voter base outside of abortion, which isn't having a very large effect and as we saw was merely the 4th most motivating thing behind inflation, crime, and immigration. And Biden's executive orders are popular, but they aren't moving the needle in terms of voting.
The point is, a huge reason Biden tanked was because he just got stonewalled at so many turns in 2021 and I feel like the public just lost confidence in the dude, especially as inflation rages on and people freak out over crime for some reason. Biden already ran with a weak agenda, but failing to achieve even most of what he set out to do made him look ineffective.
3) Republican politicking is effective
Republicans are masters at framing things, and while not immune to the same problems as the democrats when they take office, given they are, since January 2021 largely not responsible for the fate of the nation outside of obstruction which they are known for, they can easily blame the republicans for everything. And given the problems we have now, they're framing the days of pre 2020 as the "good old days" with Trump being responsible for a large expanding economy with low inflation and how democrats screwed everything up.
On inflation, the republicans have embraced the meme of "let's go Brandon" and blaming it all on Biden. It should be noted Biden didn't really do anything to cause this, but he's being blamed for it. His stimulus checks are being blamed, despite Trump cutting checks too last year. His unemployment expansion is being blamed, although that's admittedly on him somewhat (I mean, it's bad imagery, paying people so much money to explicitly NOT work regardless of the reality of the situation). He;s being blamed for gas prices for some reason. He's being blamed for everything wrong with the economy. The republicans have dusted off some of their Reagan era arguments they used against Carter and are blaming them on Biden. They make it look like Biden's stimulus of the economy and "people not wanting to work" are responsible for all of the problems, and of course corporate america and a lot of small business people who lean republican and seem entitled to other peoples' labor are screaming they can't get help and blah blah blah this is Biden's fault. Now, we discussed Biden's unemployment policy on here. The money is a lot, and I kind of find the idea cringe vs say a basic income, and I've heard ANECDOTES suggesting people were putting off getting jobs due to the money, but at the same time, I haven't found any social science evidence suggesting widespread refusal to work due to the money, and that money is long gone and inflation still remains high. Still, something you'll notice about republicans is it doesn't matter what the reality is, if they can link the problems to Biden's policies, regardless of the validity of these accusations, they can blame Biden for these problems.
The same thing happens with crime. I tried looking up crime statistics, but it's really hard to get a picture on crime right now. A lot of stats lag a few years, and the most recent numbers I've seen are from...2020. Where murders went up but property crimes went down. I was under the impression that the shutdowns reduced a lot of street crime, and now that the economy has opened back up and crime is going up again, but I really don't have solid numbers. Regardless, numbers don't matter to the right. Feelings do. And they're taking advantage of the situation to hype up a huge crime wave so they can push their authoritarian law and order crap. We need a conservative president who will be tough on crime and blah blah blah. Age old republican trick on modern politics.
And you know what they're also using to blame the crime on? WOKEISM! They're claiming the reason crime rates are up is all of this defund the police crap and blah blah blah. And the far left is tough on crime. Here in PA, they're slamming John Fetterman on a lot of crime related stuff, claiming he's soft on crime because he wanted to pardon murderers or something. And its working. Fetterman is down to like +2 vs Oz.
To go more into Fetterman, they're really putting out all the stops. While Fetterman was strong out of the gate and was de facto murdering Oz in the polls, flooding the airwaves with negative ads is working for Oz. Now Oz is being accused of pardoning murderers, being a far left free loader who wants to raise taxes, etc. And he's coming under fire due to having a stroke and struggling to hear people properly, with his fitness for office coming under question. And again, all of this is working.
Going back to Biden, the same attacks are working there too. Biden is old, and a bit...weird sometimes due to his age. He's missing a few steps and it makes people question his mental fitness for the job, with many on the right accusing Biden of having dementia. Never mind the fact that Trump has a family history of dementia and a lot of his behavior in recent years sounds literally like early to mid stage dementia to me, but they think Biden is losing his marbles because he sometimes struggles without a teleprompter or goes into the wrong room or something. I admit the country is kind of "weekend at Bernies"ing Biden and the dude is probably too old to serve, but I don't think he's that bad off. More competent than Trump.
But yeah. The republicans are just playing really good politics, attacking Biden on everything and blaming it on his policies. And it's convincing to people.
4) The "wokeness" problem
I'm sorry, but the democrats have a huge problem with wokeness. It's one of the reasons the democrats seem weak on crime. All of this BLM stuff and defund the police and ACAB. The left has turned police into a cultural issue, with the left hating the police merely for existing, and the right supporting the police in a weird jingoistic fashion. I'm honestly a cultural centrist on these issues but here's the thing. When I was a kid or teenager or young adult growing up, my dad would always go on about leftists doing stuff like this. He was a vietnam vet, and when he came back he was often called a "baby killer" by people in Port Authority in NYC when getting back. And this actually caused him to hate leftists. To be fair, he's always had a chip over his shoulder on the vietnam stuff and I don't really agree with that, but I think that something that the left needs to learn to do is criticize the institutions without demonizing people within them. The left attacks police. They HATE police. And do to my sociology/criminology background, I KNOW people who are cops now. I went to school with them. And a lot of them are fairly conservative, despite having the same education that turned me as liberal as I am. Why? because the left demonizes them. "All cops are bastards". "Defund the police", "abolish the police." This stuff puts people on the defensive and makes them overcompensate by becoming more conservative. So by picking a culture war on this stuff, then people start being flag waving jingoists where criticizing the institution is akin to attacking the members, and in the police sense we got people pushing thin blue line and blah blah blah. Speaking of which, I won't give more details, but one of my friends from college was a state trooper who was killed in the line of duty this year. And the person who killed them is being treated fairly softly, and it seems to be related to a lot of BLM type stuff. The perpetrator got bail, they got charges dropped against them, blah blah blah. it's a joke. And meanwhile the family is frustrated and just wants justice. But, as the right would say, cops are afraid to do their jobs. And criminals are treated lightly. And this BREEDS right wing sentiment.
I'm not saying the right is...right on this question by the way, when I say I'm a centrist on these issues, I mean I'm actually a centrist. I sympathize with BLM and the like sometimes, but I also understand the police's side of things. And I think that the left is committing cultural genocide by allowing all of these radical left activists speak for them on these issues. It just literally provides fodder for the right to thrive on. They LIVE for controversy and outrage. Some pink haired weirdo does something that goes viral and millions of right wingers are like OMG LOOK AT THAT LOOK AT THAT and recruiting for their causes.
And we know in 2021, the democrats flopped HARD on the wokeness stuff in places like relatively blue Virginia. Really, this stuff is LOSING people on the left, and driving people to the right. We got stuff like the 1619 project in schools and fearmongering over trans issues causing republicans to push crazy laws censoring certain topics (since the right sees fighting over the education system as worth their while, if they control the agenda taught in schools rather than the left, more people will grow up leaning right in the future). And yeah, I feel like the left is pushing this stuff too hard.
As we know, the left has trouble taking a "no" on this stuff too. if you criticize or point this stuff out, they'll scream you're racist, you're sexist, you're privileged, you're bigoted, blah blah blah. Insane tribalism from those guys. but you know what? They need to learn this. They are alienating people. ANd they are making the right stronger with their obnoxiousness and self righteousness.
Also, as I said, I feel like the dems DO have a white male problem. Look at the statistics on who votes for whom. You'll see that groups that benefit from critical theory do quite well with democrats. but they lose badly, especially with uneducated white males. I'm an educated white male, with my education giving me some level of nuance, hence my "centrism" on this issue, but a lot of people less educated than me have turned hard against this stuff to the point of being anti intellectual. And the left is just digging in and shooting the messenger when I try to point this out. Well, hey, your funeral guys. Maybe you win democratic primaries with that stuff, but then you alienate people in the general. We need a more broad ethos that actually appeals to everyone, quite frankly.
5) Mismatch in priorities
As I said, the issues that are influencing voters are issues that the right does better on right now. The economic messaging of the right is demonizing the left and driving people right. The left is looking bad on crime. Wokeness which is heavily emphasized on the left is turning people off. And the most uniting democratic issue right now, abortion, just isn't having a major impact. Biden did some cool things with student loans and the like, but given millions of Americans dont even have student loans, and the republicans are framing is as "the left are raising your taxes to pay for rich kids' college", a lot of the impact isn't really widespread through the economy and the issue is becoming divisive. Btw, I'm not saying forgiving student loans is bad. I'm just saying it's not really motivating people right now. I literally have pushed for student debt forgiveness since 2016 and I think it needs to go further. But I also understand that between centrist dems and the right poisoning the well on it, it's actually becoming divisive and not paying for dems as much as it should. It is a HUGE reason why im actually so gung ho on the dems this year, but it isn't playing well with the larger voting base, with some being for it, some being against and the net impact being neutral to slightly negative due to all the OMG EXECUTIVE OVERREACH! people.
The fact is, immigration, crime, and inflation are the big drivers driving people to the polls, and all of those issues favor republicans. Abortion, forgiving drug offenders, and student loan forgiveness are motivating the left, but it isn't quite having as pronounced impact as it should. Republican enthusiasm is way up, democratic enthusiasm is way down.
6) The original sin of 2016
Virtually everything that happened is because of the way 2016 played out. The fact is, when we had this realignment, or the beginning of it at least, the GOP got the better end of the deal again. They were able to get all of the populist energy in their party and have cultivated a loyal and fanatical voter base that is seemingly ignorant of facts into their party. These guys love the GOP and will turn up regularly, screaming about how the democrats are destroying America while acting like Trump was the greatest thing since sliced bread.
With Hillary, the democrats got the crap end of the deal. Democrats lack enthusiasm. They seem to suck at messaging. They seem to be unwilling to do things to save their life, and then when they try people turn against it because the left is very divided between the centrist and leftist factions. And they can't seem to drive people to the polls without the boogeyman of the republicans. They can run AGAINST the right when the right is in power and pick up seats just being the alternative to the right, but they can't stand on their own two feet without falling apart. They inspire no one, their fixes are incremental, when they do things people then scream it goes too far, and the right just bullies them back to the center. It's frustrating to watch.
And finally...one more thing I have to bring up
7) Lefties actually do seem like unreliable voters
One of the excuses I always hear about the left not doing anything is that when they do lefties dont turn out for them. Lefties are horridly unreliable voters. To some extent I do blame the dems for this. The dems alienate a lot of people from supporting them. LIKE ME. I didnt support them in 2016 and 2020 because they dont support left wing policy. But when they try to support left wing policy, it isn't helping. Biden's calls to codify roe v wade are falling on deaf ears. Student loan forgiveness and pardoning drug offenders isnt moving the needle. And a lot of people just dont vote. Especially in my age range. I have a friend who i talk politics with all the time. He aint voting. Granted, he lives in NY, but when I showed him his congressional seat is up for grabs he was just like "you mean I have to go to my voting place and take time out of my day to vote?" YES, PLEASE GO VOTE. He isn't going to. Mainly out of sheer laziness, but I think this is a problem with the under 40s. The reason why politics is dominated by boomers and gen X, who both lead very conservative, is because THEY VOTE. Millennials and Zoomers are like...gee, do I have to? Yeah if you want to actually change things, YES. This is especially why insurgeant compaigns like Sanders and Yang fail so hard. Because their constituents are not the ones who actually make the important decisions. many of them aren't registered, if they are they arent registered as democrats, and if they are they still dont show up. Many people seem completely unwilling to actually get out there and vote. And it's frustrating. You cant complain they dont' listen to you if you dont actually make your voice heard.
Take note my own voting strategy. I might not always vote for democrats, but I vote. I take the effort to make my voice heard. It might not always be for the dems. It might be green, I might even leave some races blank intentionally to spite the dems. But I do actually make my vote a carrot and a stick. You cant say you are using a carrot and a stick unless you actually follow through with the carrot. If the democrats actually do nice things for you, YOU HAVE TO REWARD THAT. If you don't, well, don't be surprised when they dont turn out for you. The reason the dems have embraced centrism and identity politics is because the centrists vote, and they got massive POC constituencies that vote. But you know who dont vote? The independents who like Bernie and Yang. Those guys dont vote. And thats why our politics arent being heard. We're like herding freaking cats, man. It's frustrating. If you dont turn out for the dems when they do cool stuff dont be surprised when they dont do cool stuff.
8) Lack of education among voters combined with poor messaging
The right doesnt have a voter problem, because the average voter isnt very smart, and the right panders to them in language they can understand. it doesnt matter if the right is factually wrong. What matters with elections is whether they connect to the emotions of people with a bare minimum knowledge in the subject. Given most voters are tired, and work hard all day, and pay taxes for social services they never see, many of them just dont vote democratic. Republicans push simplistic ideas. Personal responsibility. Work = success. The american dream. The left has a lot of sociology supporting their ideas, but do they really connect that stuff to voters? no. It's hard to explain to right wingers why inflation isnt caused by $1400 checks and unemployment. You need to write a literal freaking essay, and they just need to repeat the same sentence over and over again. The wokies. They have all of this stuff you literally need a 300 level college course to understand (source: learned about their theories in 300 level sociology and political theory courses), and most Americans don't have that. And even worse a lot of people on the right have literal dunning kruger syndrome and see all of these college educated people going left and think that the left is brainwashing them and that they know best. Republicans have convinced the salt of the earth, the average white male car mechanic making $30-40k a year, that he knows just as much as the experts. And he believes them. He thinks the world is simple. While left wing ideas are complicated.
The left is, quite frankly, at a disadvantage, because left wing ideas based on complex social theory are difficult for the average voter to grasp, and right wing ideas are BS that sounds good and attractive to undereducated people. We really do have an educational problem with this country. This is half the reason im for free college. We need educated citizens who are more able to understand and grapple with issues. Instead most voters are woefully ignorant of policy, and this favors the right, who peddle simple ideas that are wrong, but intuitively grasped by the voter base.
Even the dems have this issue. Keep in mind the criticisms leveled at Bernie bros. Oh, we have all of this college education and theory and most working class voters dont get it. Therefore vote for worthless centrists who pander identity politics. Yeah, Im calling out the dems for exploiting this too. Being educated in America, particularly deeply educated in the social sciences like I am, is extremely frustrating. It's like watching tons of ignorant people who dont understand anything have these opinions that are cringey as fudge, and these guys decide who gets into office. Imagine if this worked in other fields. Imagine if doctors were told by random people how to do surgery. or engineers were told how to build bridges by some dude who never studied physics in their life. That's political life in the US. Democracy might be the least bad system, and Im not advocating for technocracy here (as that just descends to oligarchy and corruption anyway), but democracy is only as good as the voters and the current environment favors ignorance and right wing policies that sound good intuitively to uneducated people but are disastrous in practice.
Conclusion
I've been pretty upset over the state of the country realizing this stuff. But yeah, thinks are screwed right now. The right is winning the political battles right now, inundating the political dialogue with tons of bad and ignorant takes, and the left is just...falling apart. Part of it is due to them not embracing a more populist ethos themselves. Part of this is due to the fact that the right is just better at messaging. Part of it is due to them not doing anything and losing the confidence of the voters, and some of it is just happening to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. But right now, I feel like the left is losing the war on ideas. As a result, the right wing seems fired up right now, while the left seems demotivated and under assault. And even populist measures to try to rally the left don't seem to be working, which isnt good. If the dems can't figure this stuff out, they may be screwed.
Anyway, I'll do a more thorough projection closer to election day, maybe in another 1-2 weeks or so. I want to wait until within a week before election day or so because I want my next prediction to be my final one. Although people are voting NOW and I voted already. But yeah, I want my final prediction to be reasonably accurate. So I won't jump the gun yet.
No comments:
Post a Comment